Wednesday, 9 November 2011

IT'S A GAS, GAS, GAS!!!

One of our regular correspondents has been telling us about a day he spent at a documentary production company back in the 90s. The head of that independent documentary company had previously been in charge of the BBC's Panorama slot, and he freely admitted that the editorial team at Panorama would say: "Right - who are we going to get, this week?"

This week, Panorama "got" renewables. Specifically, offshore windfarms. And boy, have they stirred up a hornet's nest!

First fact: the Panorama programme modelled its argument on an energy report drawn up by KPMG. This report has not been published yet, and there is some doubt as to whether or not it will be (see: http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/news/2123108/wind-power-sector-slams-flawed-kpmg-energy-report). The KPMG report seems to have argued that renewables will force energy bills up, leading to increased levels of fuel poverty, and that new nuclear and gas-fired power stations would be cheaper.

This is a very odd claim, and one wonders whether KMPG's findings are in any way related to the fact that it has recently secured lucrative employment advising the Russian gas giant Gazprom on its gas pipeline exporting gas to Western Europe (http://www.globalgastransport.info/archive.php?id=2358). Or, to put it another way, while a company is making money out of a Russian gas pipeline, can that same company be trusted not to try and push gas as the "best" form of electricity generation in the UK?

It's a valid question, because Ofgem currently recognises that no less than 56% of the average consumer's bill is based on the cost of wholesale gas. In other words, half of your energy bills cover the costs of importing the gas which is burned to create electricity. That cost is set to rise, probably dramatically, as international demand for gas grows (in Japan, for example, where their nuclear embarrassment has led to a "dash for gas"). Already, wholesale gas prices for this winter are 40% higher than they were last winter, and those costs will be passed on directly to the consumer.

By contrast, renewables (that's ALL renewables, not just wind) account for no more than £20 per year on the average bill for domestic energy use. The average domestic gas bill, meanwhile, increased by roughly £170 last year. So which is the most expensive source for electricity, at least as far as the consumer is concerned? Well, it's gas, obviously.

Which KPMG are trying to argue is "cheaper" than renewables.

Go figure.

Second fact: the Panorama programme was presented by Tom Heap, who happily describes himself as an "Eco-Sceptic" (http://tomheap.com/?page_id=196). In plain English, this means that Tom Heap does not much care for environmentalists or anyone who is growing increasingly concerned about climate change and our irresponsible attitudes towards sustainability. In this, Heap seems to be at odds with the global scientific consensus and the International Energy Agency, which is now warning that we are rapidly running out of time to deal with the terrifying problems of climate change (http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/news/2123758/world-headed-irreversible-climate-change-iea-warns). In the face of these scientific warnings, Heap's one-sided approach to pressing issues is astonishingly irresponsible.

Usually, the BBC is constrained by the slightly difficult concept of "balance". It is this very "balance" which often confuses important debates - for example, even though the vast majority of scientists agree that climate change is happening and it's probably down to humankind's activities, the rules of "balance" mean that some crackpot has to be interviewed to represent the opposing viewpoint of a tiny and deluded minority.

But Heap didn't bother with balance at all in his Panorama puff-piece for the fossil fuel industries (gas and nuclear). Not one activist, campaigner, expert, representative, lobbyist or scientist was allowed to argue the case for renewables. Not one.

So - a reporter who does like the green movement bases a totally one-sided piece based on a skewed report written (but not yet published) by an accountancy firm with an interest in fossil fuels. In the circumstances, there's hardly any wonder that Heap and the Panorama team did not dare to interview anyone from the pro-renewables side of the argument. If they had, the "reporter" and his silly claims would have been made to look extremely stupid. But, as we've noted elsewhere, the anti-renewables loonies don't like debate. It scares them. If you trying to defend an indefensible position, do not open it up for debate. Simples.

Fortunately, it looks like many individuals, groups and organisations are preparing detailed complaints to the BBC over this outrageously lousy piece of reporting. The question is, will it make the slightest bit of difference? The BBC has colluded in a rather blatant attempt to shackle the UK energy consumer to a generation source that is not renewable, will only go up in cost and will do nothing to help curb global warming - and for whose benefit?

Answer: KPMG and its clients, of course.

Saturday, 5 November 2011

DUPLICRACY


For those who chanced to see it, it was a chilling moment.

January, 2011. Outside a District Council offices in the English Midlands. A lone supporter of a windfarm planning application explains to a local TV news reporter that the planning committee meeting which is about to start will be the first open debate about the proposed windfarm in over two years. An anti-windfarm protest group had actively prevented any form of intelligent, rational, informed debate from taking place. That sole supporter was instantly jeered, heckled and insulted by the crowd of 100+ anti's, all gathered around him in a semi-circle, all wearing their screaming yellow T-shirts and brandishing banners.

It went out live on the lunchtime news. The mob-rule, which residents of the village of Church Lench had complained of, was momentarily visible for the whole of the region to see. Anyone who expressed a divergent opinion was shouted down. There had been no debate. The majority of the protesters were protesting against something they did not understand because their leaders had ruthlessly misinformed them, heightening their ignorance, and had systematically obstructed any real facts from getting through.

That is how the anti-windfarm minority conducts itself. It refuses to allow any form of debate. Rather, it heckles, hectors, harasses and harangues. It doesn't want to discuss. It merely shouts.

This is becoming a major problem. If you visit an anti-windfarm (or anti-renewables) website and try to leave a pro-wind comment, the chances are that the "moderators" of that site will block it. If you visit a pro-wind (or green business) website, you will find that deranged souls have been trolling that site, plastering their nonsensical, unsubstantiated and waywardly inaccurate anti-wind power claims all over it.

One would hope that those who want to get the latest news about developments in the world of renewables would be able to do so without risk of harassment or having to wade through the sick dribblings of the anti-wind loonies and the demented climate change deniers. No such luck. Question those mentalists on their own websites and they'll silence you. But on pro-renewables websites, the same mentalists consider it open season.

This tells us a lot about the state of play in the great windfarm "debate". Keep an eye on what's happening around the world and you'll quickly realise that renewables are the primary energy source of the 21st century. That's what's happening. But there are some very twisted souls who don't want that.

Some are no doubt working for the fossil fuels/nuclear lobbies. Some are just opinionated weirdos who won't shut up. Some got a bee in their bonnets over a local windfarm application and now see it as their mission to oppose wind turbines anywhere and everywhere. Some just read useless right-wing scare-sheets and believe all the rubbish they're told. But they all have one thing in common. They believe that their opinions are right and that no one else should be entitled to one.

It's interesting to see how the nimbies exploit the notion of democracy. If a windfarm is refused planning approval, they declare a victory for "democracy" (regardless of the fact that they themselves are in the minority). Alternatively, should a local council go with the science, the evidence, the clear and pressing need and the majority opinion, these same witless dupes announce that "democracy" has counted for nothing.

Their notion of democracy means one thing and one thing only: it's what they want, irrespective of what everyone else wants.

To achieve their ends, they wilfully undermine all forms of democracy. In the battle of Lenchwick, parish councils were attacked: one was forced to resign and was replaced with representatives of the fraudulent protest group VVASP. Independent parish councillors were warned that they were "not allowed" to express their opinions in public, while the VVASP parish councils could make their feelings known whenever and however they felt like it. Public money was appropriated under false pretences and diverted into a political anti-windfarm campaign. The district council was tricked by these same single-issue "parish councillors" into hiring a noise consultant who regularly works for an anti-windfarm lobbying organisation. Local surveys were grossly misrepresented, and the falsified figures read out at the planning meeting by a pet Tory MP. Lies were published, and when those lies were successfully challenged, more lies were told. Any local resident who went "off message" and pointed out a fact about windfarms - such as, they're not noisy at all - was victimised. Some were threatened.

Lies, falsification, thuggery and mob rule have no place in democracy. You either believe in free speech or you don't. Anti-wind nimbies don't. They'll demand it for themselves, but they'll prevent others from exercising the same rights.

They'll interfere with green websites to spread their deluded nonsense but they won't allow any genuine facts onto their own websites, in spite of their duplicitous claims to be giving out "comprehensive information". They'll tell lies about local supporters, windfarm developers, governments and scientists, but they won't allow the other side of the story to be told. They'll squeal to the local papers and the police if their grotesque protest signs are removed from public property, while at the same time removing and destroying any pro-windfarm signs that might appear in appropriate places.

The whole windfarm debate is not a debate at all. It's a one-sided slanging match conducted by idiots who don't want their neighbours to hear the facts. They make up facts which aren't true and then accuse the other side of lying. They pretend that they are the victims of a multi-national green conspiracy while they victimise their own neighbours for expressing honest opinions. They will purposefully undermine local democracy and then declare a victory for local democracy.

Any country which allows this sort of behaviour to succeed is in big trouble. Naturally, the Tories pander to these lunatics because the majority of them are Tory voters. But in doing so, they are sanctioning the mindless destruction of democracy by an unscrupulous minority of fanatics. Those MPs who thoughtlessly offer support to these fascist mobs and their despicably selfish and deceitful ringleaders are guilty of undermining what little we have left in the way of democracy.

Perhaps the tide is turning. Even climate change skeptics are finally realising that, yes, the Earth is warming up - see here:

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/04/opinion/dr-mullers-findings-on-global-warming.html?_r=3

That's a good thing, because it shows that, after too many years of denial, even the skeptics are beginning to acknowledge the truth. The next step is to accept that we need to be implementing strategies to curb the worst effects of global warming. And that means two things: sustainability and renewables.

The arguments against windfarms are fading thick and fast - largely because those arguments were bogus and dishonest in the first place. Anti-windfarm protesters fall into two categories: those who are merely opposed to change in any form whatsoever, and those who have been terrorised by the first bunch into believing a pack of lies about windfarms. We should feel sorry for the latter group and do our best to enlighten them with the evidence. The first bunch are the real enemy, for it is they who systematically destroy local democracy and their own communities in order to force others to obey them.

We have a moral duty to oppose these deluded fanatics at every turn. Okay, so we in the pro-wind camp are not afraid of open debate, while our nimby opponents are terrified of open debate. Okay, so we believe in free speech while the nimby nutters in our midst absolutely oppose it. And okay, so we champion democracy while the anti's seek to destroy it, because that's the only way they can force their petty-minded, greedy, stupid, arrogant views on everybody else.

Because they refuse to play by the rules, we have to be ready, willing and able to stand up to their meaningless lies, their bullying tactics, their evil intentions. They demand free speech for themselves and deny it to everyone else. So we must exercise our rights to free speech in order to come down hard on their crazy insinuations, their false evidence, their scaremongering gibberish.

We can't expect them to debate the issues with us. They don't want a debate. It would make them look foolish. They can only prevail if no one gets to hear the genuine facts.

Which is why we must lose no opportunity to expose them as the unprincipled liars they are, again and again and again. Free speech is a precious thing. We mustn't let them abuse it on order to shut down the debate.

Wednesday, 2 November 2011

BLOWING OUR OWN TRUMPET

They're a very smallscale operation, but the good folks at Yes 2 Wind do a very good job. Their website is improving all the time, and if there is one thing that is definitely needed it is a source of reliable information about windfarms. The only hope is those who seek reliable information can get to it before the fanatical disinformation artists of the anti-renewables fringe get to them.

One of the innovations on the Yes 2 Wind website is their "Windypedia" section - a kind of Wikipedia for windfarm-related issues. And we here at Wind of Change are extremely proud to have been involved with this.

Basically, all that time spent trying to set the record straight, after our local nimbies had poisoned the well of truth by spreading so many hysterical lies about windfarms, has in fact been very useful. While it was all too easy for Big Chief Nookie to spread false information about the impact of a windfarm on local property values, those of us with a working conscience had to put a bit more effort into finding out the facts.

All that hard work and research can now be put to good use, so that - with any luck - not quite so many people will be misled by self-serving propagandists.

This link takes you to the Yes 2 Wind page about house prices, with a major contribution from ourselves on the "Expert" page:

http://www.yes2wind.com/faqs/property-values/do-wind-farms-affect-property-values#

This might not be the last word on the subject. There is a university paper currently being drafted which looks at the issue in detail, and its preliminary findings indicate that any impact on house prices is actually caused by mindless nimby idiots and not by actual windfarms. As the report's author has put it, "they're shooting themselves in the foot".

Interesting, isn't it, that during these times of austerity and economic uncertainty, the money-minded maniacs of the anti-windfarm brigade are harming their own finances, as well as those of their all-too trusting neighbours?

Monday, 31 October 2011

PROTESTERS ADMIT THEY WERE WRONG

It's the same old story. Fanatics trick people into believing that windfarms are "noisy". Those people then put pressure on their local authorities to block windfarm developments. But if the windfarm gets built, those same people soon discover an important fact:

WINDFARMS ARE NOT NOISY!

As these former protesters in Leicestershire are now admitting:

http://thisisleicestershire.co.uk/wrong-turbine-noise-admit-protesters/story-13713002-detail/story.html

We've said it before. Every windfarm that gets installed and starts operating is another challenge to the lies of the fanatical anti-wind brigade.

Noise. It's one of the main reasons Wychavon District Council gave for refusing planning permission for the proposed Lenchwick Windfarm. Next time, we'll just have to point them towards the good people of Leicestershire, who were similarly tricked and misled - only now, they know better.

Saturday, 29 October 2011

A CALL TO ARMS

Hi folks!

Wind of Change has been a bit quiet lately. This is because there was some extremely bad news back in the summer. ScottishPower Renewables decided not to appeal the planning decision which, thanks to the crazen boobs of Wychavon District Council, denied the community a valuable and attractive resource - namely, one rather magnificent windfarm.

The reasons given for the Council's decision were nonsensical. Given that polls consistently show that the majority of Britons support wind power, and that the majority of people in Worcestershire want windfarms, and that the most ardent supporters of wind energy are those who live near windfarms, and given the study commissioned by the local authority that Church Lench was the ideal site for a windfarm, it seemed a little bit strange that the misinformed council members should have decided that a few reckless and dishonest nimbies were right.

In other words, surveys, polls, scientific studies, common sense and the weight of evidence counted for nothing. But the fanatics of VVASP with their falsehoods and hysteria were right.

You could say that four people managed to deprive thousands of cheap, clean, green electricity. They even prevented their neighbours from benefitting through the mini property boom which usually follows on from the installation of a windfarm. They lied, hectored, harrassed, harangued, posed, postured, screamed and shouted. And rather than defending democracy and representing the people, the elected members and the wretched sock-puppet of an MP stood foursquare behind the narrow-minded, the misguided, the brainwashed and the corrupt.

ScottishPower Renewables know that there is a great future for renewables in Scotland, whereas anywhere south of the River Trent instantly turns into a seething cesspit of middle-class nimbies all spouting the same idiotic nonsense whenever a windfarm is mentioned. So, understandably, SPR decided to devote its energies to fighting the good fight in a sane and intelligent country. Okay, so there are a few little Englanders who have infiltrated Scotland and are up to their usual tricks - intolerance, belligerence, arrogance, etc. - but by and large, Scotland is showing the way, while England lags behind, moaning and whinging about everything.

As a measure of how well Scotland is doing, output from windfarms grew by a massive 120% in the first half of this year. At the same time, hydroelectric schemes increased their output by 75%. This meant that, even in an unusually dry and calm year, Scotland's renewable sector met more than THIRTY PER CENT of the total electricity demand from homes and businesses in Scotland.

That deserves a fanfare.

Okay, so what has England been up to in the meantime?

Well, the liars have been out in force, with the result that the notoriously cumbersome planning system is collapsing under the weight of nimby crap. In the UK as a whole, approval rates for new onshore windfarms in the UK fell to 42% in 2010-11. In England, it was as low as 26%, and the process is taking ever longer, thanks to the lies and grubby tactics of the VVASP types. The average amount of time it now takes for a vital energy infrastructure project to get planning approval has risen from 24 to 33 months.

There is no good reason for this. Politicians are largely to blame - like the Tory MP who is currently opposing a windfarm proposal in his Stroud constituency while, up in Northumberland, where he actually lives, he is actively trying to get a windfarm on his own land. That kind of hypocrisy is killing Britain.

There is no sound reason whatsoever for the middle-class anti-wind rebellion in England. There are lots of fake and phoney reasons, mostly to do with the idea that when you buy your nice little place in the country you reserve the right to prevent anything at all from ever happening anywhere nearby. Which is foolish, selfish, undemocratic and plain stupid. But that's nimbies for you.

Wind of Change was going to wait for another developer to come along and challenge the frauds, the fools, the liars and the thugs of our local nimby fraternity. After all, Wychavon will have to live up to its responsibilities some day, and the issue of sustainability and renewables is not going to go away.

Furthermore, even though nimby nutters have managed to make it almost impossible for Britain to meet her obligations and do the right thing for present and future generations, windfarms are still getting planning permission. And every windfarm that starts operating is another indictment of the fraudulent and dishonest methods of the nimbies. They can only get away with pretending that windfarms are "noisy" when the majority of their ovine neighbours don't know anything about windfarms. The more windfarms there are, the more the dimwits will struggle to tell lies about them.

But the figures are appalling, really. The rest of the world is steaming ahead with renewables. In Britain, we're just squabbling about them. There is no debate on the issue - just a bunch of liars on one side trying to confuse, addle, terrify and mislead the public, while the developers of renewables are being prevented from guaranteeing our energy security. The Mad Hatters of the nimby fringe really do want more nuclear accidents, more expensive electricity, coal imports from countries that use child labour, massive payments of taxpayers' money to corrupt regimes, more pollution, more blackouts, more national humiliation ... just so that they need not glimpse a wind turbine from the window of their spare bedroom. How insane is that?

Well, here's the news: the WWF has announced that the UK could secure up to 90% of its electricity needs from renewables by 2030. No need for new nuclear. Wind, solar, wave, tidal could pretty much do it all. Cheaper than the alternatives. Cleaner and healthier than the alternatives. Here's the report:

http://assets.wwf.org.uk/downloads/positive_energy_final_designed.pdf

Yes, it's possible. But it will require a government that puts Britain's interests first, rather than the self-interest of a few idiots who simply can't tell the truth.

So Wind of Change is back. We can't let the lunatic fringe continue to dictate matters of the gravest national importance by constantly spreading lies. We - the patriots of Britain, the lovers of the land, the caring, conscientious ones - must stand and fight these self-centred lunatics. We must oppose the fascist tactics they use to get their way. We must press the case for the common interest, the greater good, the planet and our children.

Let's hold the government to account. And let's counter the lies of the nimbies with the truth.

The battle starts now.

Monday, 11 July 2011

PRESS FREEDOM

When the prime minister, David Cameron, announced last week that proper regulation of the press in the UK will be introduced in the wake of the phone-hacking scandals, two newspapers got straight on the phone to 10 Downing Street to whinge their heads off about the proposed regulatory body.

Those papers were the Mail and the Telegraph. Why, we might wonder, are those two right-wing papers so opposed to any form of meaningful press regulation?

Well, the Mail was heavily criticised by the Information Commissioner a few years ago for its eagerness to acquire confidential personal information by illegal means. But, more importantly, neither paper wants to see an end to its freedom to publish made-up, inaccurate and grossly misleading stories.

It's no coincidence that both the Mail and the Telegraph have a shameful track record of publishing absolute nonsense concerning green energy, renewables and, in particular, wind power. Even today, Chris Huhne MP, Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change, was obliged to respond to a hysterical campaign of lies, launched by those two offending newspaper groups, regarding "green taxes". The Mail and the Telegraph are trying to pretend that the costs of renewable energy are going to lead to a 30% hike in electricity bills. Not true, but why let simple facts get in the way of a story guaranteed to get middle class hackles raised?

Proper regulation of the press is just one of the desirable outcomes of the Murdoch debacle. Basically, the UK has become a country which feeds on lies, false stories and outrageous propaganda. Bring in proper regulation, and it will be difficult for papers like the Mail and the Telegraph to continue their demented anti-renewables stance. At least, they'll have to base their stories on facts, and not total garbage.

That can be nothing but good news for supporters of wind energy. Under the Murdoch reign of terror, it has become commonplace in Britain for he who lies loudest to win the argument - a tactic deployed by nimby groups like VVASP in place of balanced, reasoned and evidence-based campaigns. By indulging in absolutely irresponsible anti-windfarm proganda, right-wing rags have given dishonest nimby groups no end of fake ammunition. That cannot continue once real regulation of the press has been introduced. The nimbies will be deprived of the fountains of lies which have allowed them to mislead themselves, each other and everybody else who will listen to them.

This means that a golden opportunity to turn Britain back into a country in which sensible, sober debate is possible, and in which lies will be exposed for what they are. That can only be a good thing. Starved of their regular drip-feed of anti-windfarm gibberish, groups like VVASP will be forced to base their anti-windfarm arguments on reality, and not the fog of lies published by treacherous and wayward right-wing rags. And once an anti-windfarm campaign is exposed to the clear light of reality, it quickly emerges as selfish, foolish and wrong.

The events of the past week should be welcomed as a big step closer to a Britain governed by facts and rational debate, rather than lies, bullying and thuggish insanity.

Good news for windfarms, then.

Friday, 1 July 2011

WHO'S FOOLING WHO?

Just yesterday we speculated on the bizarre, topsy-turvy debate of nuclear versus renewables.

How, for instance, certain propagandists are so eager to accuse windfarms of things that, in fact, it is nuclear that is really guilty of.

Some of the more barking anti-wind propagandists go to the extreme of conjuring up a fantastic conspiracy, at the centre of which is those arch-magicians at the Department for Energy and Climate Change. Those are the scary civil servants who are somehow brainwashing some of us into thinking that wind turbines are actually quite beautiful. They're the dangerous cabal behind all windfarm promotion in the UK (and, presumably, beyond). They have got into bed with the windpower industry and are forcing us all to go down the renewable road.

Hmmnn ... Sound realistic to you?

Well here's something. It's not the renewables industry that the British government is conspiring with. It's nuclear. Read this:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/jun/30/british-government-plan-play-down-fukushima?CMP=EMCGT_010711&

Once again, we find that all the naughty things the maniacs out there like to attribute to the windpower industry are totally misplaced. It's the nuclear folk who are up to no good.

You really do have to wonder about the motivations of those "useful idiots" and crazed, deluded, utterly dishonest anti-windfarm campaigners. Are they really trying to dispose of a safe, clean, green alternative to the nuclear nightmare?

Looks like it, doesn't it?