Tuesday, 29 September 2009

PLACARD FEVER - LATEST

It can be so difficult explaining to a nimby the difference between public and private.
They're okay with the 'private' - i.e., belongs to them. But they struggle with the 'public' because they think that belongs to them as well.
Take this image, sent in recently. Somebody must have seen the Men-At-Work sign and assumed that it was theirs to deface.
The struggle to understand what is theirs and what isn't lies behind much of the windfarm debate.
For instance, several people seem to imagine that when they bought their houses in the Lenches - not so very long ago, in most cases - they also purchased a field several hundred metres away.
They don't really want that field (too much work), but they reserve the right to decide what happens in it.
In other words, it's not theirs. But they like to think that it is.
Similarly, there are some who believe that when they bought their house, they also bought the view. And that it would remain forever unchanged.
Who told them that??
No one owns a view.
Lenchwick Windfarm, when it is up and running, will cleanly and quietly generate enough electricity to power several thousand homes. Till then, though, we'll keep hearing from several dozen homes who think they own the area. Which they don't. And who think that the view (which they don't own) is more important, in the grand scheme of things, than those households which will be powered by the windfarm.
And more public property will be defaced by people who think that they own it.
So - a warning. Don't stand still for long in the Lenches. Someone is bound to think that you belong to them and stick a placard on you.

Sunday, 27 September 2009

THAT WAS THE WEEK THAT WAS

Exciting times!

This week, VVASP finally remembered that they were supposed to be 'Pro-Renewables'. Their spokesperson gave a ringing endorsement of windpower ... as long as it is out at sea, where no one in the Lenches can see it.

The endorsement came as the result of a heartfelt and effective letter, written by two local teenagers and printed in the Evesham Journal. This is not the first time that the youth of the area have engaged in the windfarm debate on the side of the angels - and, let's face it, it's their voice that matters most.

For a start, they haven't fallen into the trap of thinking they own the views from their windows (a quick look at title deeds should disabuse the selfish nimbies of the Lenches of that misguided notion). More importantly, it is their generation which will have to cope with the damage caused by the nimby generation.

Unusually, though, the newspaper editor offered VVASP an immediate right to reply. Perhaps he was seeking to avoid a torrent of barely literate, spume-spattered nonsense emanating from brainwashed nimbies. Perhaps he knew that if he gave the VVASP a right to reply, they'd say something typically stupid and wrong.

VVASP took the opportunity to witter about the 'information' on their website (mostly non-existent, the rest is just hogwash) and to say, "If they can put wind farms offshore I'm 100 per cent behind it."

Now they only have to get tractors, combine harvesters, airplanes, helicopters, motorbikes, dumper trucks, lorries, 4x4s and music festivals sited offshore and they can look forward to a quiet life.

A clue to the kind of propaganda VVASP has been showing to the ego-warriors of Lench also came to light this week. Judging by some of the fantastical gibberish being spouted by VVASP supporters, the nimby group has been screening 'The War of the Worlds'. Little old ladies do seem to believe that offshore windfarms are marching onshore to clutter up the English countryside (they never seem to worry when windfarms are constructed in Wales or Scotland) and to fire their evil death-rays into middle class homes.

Actually, Peter Luff MP seems to be partly responsible for this. His line would appear to be that windfarms were developed for offshore use and are only now being built onshore. This is a slightly bizarre reading of recent history. And, thinking about it, given that the nimbies have been brainwashed into droning that onshore windfarms are 'too expensive' all the time, offshore windfarms would hardly seem to be the solution.

But VVASP and consistency are like Hugh Hefner and monogamy. Peter Luff has previously described VVASP's claims as 'overly dramatic' and appears privately to feel that Lenchwick Windfarm will go ahead. So his public statements are there only to stroke the egos of the nimbies and shouldn't be taken too seriously.

This past week, ScottishPower Renewables made it possible for locals to find out more about the proposed windfarm. They were greeted with some fine displays of traditional rural pursuits - such as Abusing the Visitors, Playing Loud Noises Till the Police Arrive, Making Up Stories, and of course there was an Olympic standard Village Idiot competition. No winner has yet been declared (the competition was just too intense), but there were some firm favourites.

One guy kept banging on that windfarms should be built 'on the edges of towns'. He clearly hasn't heard of such places as Oxford, Glasgow, Rochdale ...

(The latter, by the way, is a classic example of nimby nonsense being ignored, even though the three main political parties jumped on the nimby bandwagon in a daft attempt at winning votes. The Scout Moor windfarm of 25 turbines is now happily, and quietly, supplying enough electricity to power half of Rochdale.)

Harvington seems to have been the quietest of the public information sessions - partly because there must be plenty of people in Harvington who now wonder whether the windfarm has got anything at all to do with them, and partly because the VVASP Nazis were saving their energies for the following evening.

Church Lench saw the height of nimby irrationality and hostility, for which the VVASP ringleaders are entirely culpable. By then, though, the BBC had lost interest in their little protest.

Overall, the public information sessions would appear to have been a remarkable success ... for supporters of the windfarm. Not only did the VVASP tactics convert several more locals into active supporters of this harmless and vital development, but early indications are that the sessions revealed a strong body of opinion in favour of Lenchwick Windfarm. Despite the nimbies' best efforts in lying and bullying everyone around them into empty-headed agreement that windfarms are 'noisy' (not true), 'expensive' (compared with what? Nuclear?), 'inefficient' (rubbish) and hazardous to house prices (balls), a surprisingly large number of people have maintained their independence, weighed up the facts, and decided that the windfarm is a Good Thing.

So - a strong base of support for Lenchwick Windfarm and lasting shame for VVASP.

Wind of Change is now eager to hear from anyone with a good, practical solution to the problem of disposing of all those ghastly nimby placards which are littering up Sheriffs Lench, Church Lench and Atch Lench. They're already an aesthetic nightmare, and we can't afford for them to become an environmental nightmare too. VVASP won't have concerned themselves with this because THE EARTH AND ALL THINGS IN IT IS THEIRS TO DO WHATEVER THEY WANT WITH, GOT IT?

But those of us with an eye on the future are going to have to advise them on the safe disposal of all their silly placards. Dumping them and burning them are both out of the question.

Any suggestions?

Friday, 25 September 2009

VVASP LIE No. 3

One thing the nimbes can't stand is someone who knows what they're on about.

Recently, a villager walked into the local watering hole and announced that he'd just had a holiday right by a windfarm and he couldn't see what all the fuss was about. That's the very opposite of what VVASP what people to hear. Of course, if they were genuinely 'Providing Information' to allow people to make an 'Informed Decision', such testimony would be rather useful. But VVASP are not there to provide real information. They're there to fill your head with cavity wall insulation.

Vale Villagers Against Sound Practice (VVASP) don't just spread silly rumours and inaccurate information. They go to great lengths to stop the spread of legitimate information.

At one of the recent ScottishPower Renewables' public information sessions, somebody or other was rabbiting VVASP nonsense at a consultant from Dulas, a Wales-based co-operative that advises on environmental projects. This resident kept saying, 'They're noisy, they're expensive!' Which, let's face it, is like marching up to a greengrocer and snarling: 'Oranges are blue and they taste of manure!' Somebody who knew nothing about the subject was telling somebody who knew a lot about the subject a load of old cobblers.

When a member of the public questioned this person's confident assertions, asking how they knew windfarms were noisy - had they ever been to one? - something strange happened.

The individual concerned said nothing. Just the merest nod to another part of the hall, and he was out of there, instantly replaced by a more aggressive member of the nimby gang.

So what were meant to be occasions when local residents could find out from the experts exactly what is being proposed turned into VVASP rallies where no scientific fact was allowed to get in the way. 'Providing Information to the Community', again - or, rather, 'Preventing Information from falling into the hands of the Community'.

Supporters of the windfarm do have a problem here, because even when you're sure of your ground (you've visited a windfarm or two, you've looked into the material, you've engaged your brain), the slipperiness of the protesters can catch you off-guard. They'll say something that is so banal, so outrageous, that the only proper response is to burst out laughing.

But windfarm supporters are polite, gentle people, and when residents are evidently distressed (thanks to VVASP's irresponsible behaviour), they don't want to laugh. They want to help, to reassure.

Sometimes, though, we can't. Take the latest VVASP lie. You can tell that it's a lie because it's growing all the time, like a dark cloud over the Lenches. Nitwits are competing with each other to see who can make the silliest statement, who can get most worked up about it.

And the first time a sensible person hears it, they're floored.

On Monday, it would seem, everybody's house had lost 30% of its value because of this windfarm. Those of us who were unaware of this - including local estate agents - only had worse to come. Because by Thursday, the predicted plummet in property values had reached 52%.

At this rate, by the middle of October every desirable residence in the Lenches will be worth about 20p (an investment opportunity if ever there was one). Come Christmas, and we'll have to stump up seven times the original value of our house just to get someone to take it off our hands!

You have to admit it: VVASP know how to get people where it hurts. Forget about whether there's any truth in it or not (there isn't, obviously) - the nimbies really know how to mess with their neighbours' heads. And they're not afraid to do it.

Well, let's run through the facts again. Why not?

The Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors (who, as we all know, all work for windfarm companies) have looked into this. In some areas, in the past, estate agents did voice opinions that an imminent windfarm might affect prices, although none of them could find evidence that it had. The RICS concluded that there was no hard evidence at all of windfarms harming the local property market.

Oxford Brookes University looked into this. They found that in one area in Cornwall, a few terraced houses were cheaper than elsewhere. But all those people dwelling in the famous terraced houses of Lenchland needn't worry, because the study then found that those houses were ex-MoD properties and were going cheap anyway. Again, no evidence of windfarms having an adverse effect.

A huge study in America, covering six years, of over 25,000 property transactions and ten large windfarm developments came up with some extraordinary results.

In the vast majority of cases, properties in proximity to a windfarm ROSE IN VALUE faster than comparable properties elsewhere.

What???

You mean - houses in the Lenches might actually INCREASE in value, thanks to the windfarm?

Well, that's what the largest study conducted so far would seem to suggest.

But if VVASP are 'Providing Information' to the community, why does nobody know this? Why does everybody seem to believe that their house is rapidly heading towards being worth next to nothing?

You'd have to ask them that. Presumably, the vision of all their neighbours descending into panic over a completely fictitious house price alarm amuses VVASP far more than the idea of them doing rather well out of the windfarm.

Or maybe the robots of VVASP have a plan to scare the Lenches' residents so much that they'll be able to snap up lots of lovely properties for development. Who knows.

But one thing is clear - if we stick to the facts, that is. All this guff about your house being worth 30% less, or 52% less, or 189% less, is sheer codswallop.

Isn't it nice of VVASP, though, to make you think that your house is worth nothing?

Thursday, 24 September 2009

THE GREAT MARCH

That wasn't ...

As the culmination of their determined efforts to disrupt all the public information sessions held this week by ScottishPower Renewables, VVASP organised a grand protest march through Church Lench on Wednesday evening.

They had been preparing for this for some time. Free placards had been distributed (so anyone who paid out a tenner for each placard a few weeks ago - D'oh!)

But come the night - disaster! The BBC didn't turn up. Possibly because they'd realised that this wasn't news, just a cheap stunt.

And if the BBC couldn't be bothered to broadcast it, VVASP couldn't be bothered to do it. Too much discipline required.

So the march was abandoned.

It's possible that some of the more lucid members of the bonkers protest group had realised how silly they would look, stomping up Main Street with their placards like a bunch of yokels brandishing pitchforks and flaming torches.

It's also possible that none of this had been arranged with the police. As the police had already had to deal with VVASP's anti-social behaviour, another clash with Her Majesty's Constabulary might not have looked too good.

Instead, the misguided maniacs descended en masse on Church Lench village hall to hurl abuse at the representatives of ScottishPower Renewables.

Half a dozen people, who were only doing their job, answering questions from the public and providing whatever information they could about Lenchwick Windfarm, found themselves confronted by hostile yobs shrieking at them that they were 'talking shit' and 'talking bollocks'.

Edifying as it was to see large, well-fed residents screaming abuse at young women, we should not imagine that this was a spontaneous outburst of anger. This had been organised. VVASP had been at every public information session, interrupting conversations, telling lies and intimidating those who held opinions different to theirs.

They weren't there to ask questions or gather facts. They were there to prove that what their initials really stand for is -

Viciousness
Vitriol
Aggression
Stupidity
Psychosis

A tiny cabal of residents, comprising the pathologically self-interested and the terminally barking, have created this madness. This is the side of the protest which they hide from the media. A mob of hysterical, confrontational locals flinging insults at young women. A gang of brainwashed brownshirts attacking innocent people.

Insanity has broken out in the Lenches. Insanity, pure and simple. Some villagers, most of whom have never been anywhere near a windfarm and haven't the foggiest idea of what they're protesting against, have put their faith in charlatans and nutters. And this is the outcome. Sheer, unadulterated madness.

The days of VVASP posing as the victims in this matter are over. They have (yet again) shown their true face. They haven't the faintest interest in the truth, the facts, or in behaving like decent citizens.

They have ruined their own villages, turning them into places of fear and loathing where a mindless gang of deluded, brainwashed crazies bully their neighbours into submission. Where no one is allowed an opinion which doesn't chime with theirs. Where debate is disallowed. Where honesty and decency have been jettisoned.

In the old Church Lench, such phenomenal rudeness to visitors would not have been tolerated. The nimbies have proven that they are not true villagers. They have no interest whatsoever in the village. They are destroying the community in the pursuit of their own crazy power games. They are liars.

Peter Luff MP will come to regret his nimby words. VVASP have terrorised the local villages for too long. Many are sickened by their disgusting behaviour, their irresponsible lies, their swaggering arrogance. Before too long, Peter Luff will wonder how he ever came to be suckered by such a nasty bunch of evil cretins.

Whatever the outcome, VVASP have lost the moral battle. Any last shred of respectability they laid claim to was annihilated on Wednesday night, when they showed themselves as they really are.

Liars. Cowards. Bullies. Fools.

Wednesday, 23 September 2009

MORE ON NOISE

What is this strange recording that VVASP tried to broadcast from the back of a truck before the police told them to turn it off?

According to VVASP, it's the sound of a windfarm.

Well, now. The Wind of Change team has quite a file of statements, growing all the time, from regular contributors and local residents who have visited or even holidayed by windfarms in the UK and in Europe. All of them report on how quiet the windfarms are, even downwind on a windy day. Two statements have recently come in regarding visits to the delightfully-named Bicker Fen, a windfarm of 13 new turbines. The noise - if that's what you want to call it - is negligible, whether directly under the blades or at varying distance from the turbines.

So what are we to make of the VVASP noise machine?

It would be unreasonable to expect VVASP to come clean about the recording. While the nimbies are busily accusing ScottishPower Renewables of telling lies (if anyone has come across a blatant untruth or misleading statement made by SPR in the Lenchwick Windfarm saga so far, please email it in and the Wind of Change team will research it), their own track record in this respect is pretty shabby.

In fact, expert opinion is now determining that VVASP's literature would incur an adverse ruling from the Advertising Standards Authority.

There are indications, however, that the recording VVASP is so proud of concerned a windfarm at Ireleth in Cumbria.

The seven-turbine windfarm at Ireleth starting operating in July 1999. There was some discrepancy between the original proposal for the windfarm and the eventual layout. While this does raise a few questions, it should be remembered that the late '90s was still back in the Dark Ages, where wind energy was concerned. Things have moved on a long way since then.

Three and a half years after the Ireleth windfarm began generating energy, Barrow Borough Council dropped a planning enforcement order against the windfarm developer. Six local residents then took out a private prosecution against the owners and operators of the windfarm on the grounds of 'noise nuisance'. Early in January 2004, a district judge ruled that the companies were not guilty of creating a 'noise nuisance'. Judge Peter Wallace had simply not been convinced by the six local residents that there was a case to answer.

Naturally, the nimbies cried foul, pretending that the judge was in the pocket of the windfarm owners and operators.

As far as the nimbies are concerned, ANYONE who disagrees with them is working for a windfarm company. But that is the point at which conspiracy theory slips into paranoia and clinical insanity. If you imagine that anyone who doesn't agree with your rather alarmist notions is in hock to the wind lobby, then you need professional help.

The Ireleth experience can be put into perspective. A study published in 2007 by Salford University concluded that complaints about noise from windfarms were remarkably rare. Over the course of a fifteen-year period, just 239 formal complaints had been made about windfarm noise. That's less than sixteen a year. There are over 300,000 complaints made every year about other forms of noise.

So - if it is a recording of Ireleth that is being played by VVASP, then it is a matter of legal record that the windfarm in question does not create a 'noise nuisance'. And it is a matter of statistical record that complaints about such noise are astonishingly few and far between.

Now, let's face it. The nimby movement is desperate to find the smoking gun, that one conclusive piece of evidence that windfarms are noisy. It would be like gold dust to them.

And supporters of the Lenchwick Windfarm would want to know what measures could be taken to protect residents from such a problem.

But the very obscurity of the VVASP recording is effectively proof that it isn't the 'smoking gun' the protesters have been looking for. If it did what it claimed to do, then anyone with half an eye on the windfarm issue, locally and nationally, would have heard about it. The supporters would be demanding answers to such questions as, 'Why is this windfarm noisy when others aren't? What's being done to overcome that problem?'

It may, or may not, be a realistic recording of a rather old and relatively primitive windfarm. By playing it at top volume, the nimbies are distorting whatever value the recording might have to them. And given VVASP's endless capacity for diseminating false or misleading information, it must be assumed that the recording isn't quite as straightforward as they want you to think it is.

Those who are interested may care to check back through this blog for an analysis of a video screened on the VVASP website. That video claimed to prove that a Cumbrian windfarm was noisy. In fact, it managed to prove nothing of the sort. If anything, a sober and serious study of the video concluded, yet again, that the 'noise nuisance' of windfarms is grossly exaggerated by nimby groups.

Out of the two - windfarms and anti-windfarm groups - there can be little doubt as to which is the noisiest.

Tuesday, 22 September 2009

POMPEII PLEBSITE FOUND

Archaeologists have discovered an astonishing new document in the ruins of Pompeii.

Known technically as a 'plebsite', the document sheds a fascinating light on the way the citizens of Pompeii failed to prepare for the disaster which destroyed their city in 79 AD.

As Dr Karl Thacker of Baden-Baden explained: 'A plebsite should not be confused with a plebiscite. A plebiscite represented the will of the people over an important matter. A plebsite was just a bunch of idiots jabbering on.'

The remains of the plebsite were discovered on the extreme edge of the city, where the locals would have been among the first to suffer the effects of the catastrophic volcanic eruption. According to Dr Thacker, it charts the attempts of a minority group to oppose plans to safeguard the city from destruction.

'A very bizarre group of people calling themselves Pompeii People Against Solutions to Vesuvius (PPASV) seems to have been, in its small way, partly responsible for the disaster. They strenuously opposed all attempts at averting it. As the plebsite shows, their arguments were quite crazy, really.'

The first stele to have been discovered appears to have been an introduction to the aims of PPASV. Translated by Dr Thacker, it declared that 'Pompeii People Against Solutions for Vesuvius are a pro-solutions for Vesuvius group, but we believe that only "appropriate" solutions should be allowed, and that means nothing near us.'

Professor Bontoni of Naples explains: 'A solution to the looming problem had been put forward. It would have been both elegant and effective. Laboratory tests have proven that the defensive measures, initiated under the Roman SPQR banner, would have mitigated the effects of the eruption, saving many homes and lives, as well as providing heat and light for the citizens.

'But, for reasons which remain obscure, this small group refused to allow the protective measures to be taken.'

As subsequent steles were unearthed, it became clear that the frantic PPASV group made a series of extraordinary claims about the defensive measures. Some cried 'witchcraft'. Others insisted that the scheme would spoil their view of the volcano, would affect the values of their properties, and even that Vesuvius was never going to blow anyway.

'One stele shows a whole bunch of bent spoons,' says Dr Thacker, 'suggesting that Pompeii People Against Solutions for Vesuvius hadn't really grasped what was being proposed.'

The PPASV plebsite is helping the experts to understand a peculiar wall frieze which has also been partly excavated. One image shows a man holding a large cockerel up to another man's ear. Dr Thacker suspects that this was an attempt at persuading people that the defences would sound a bit like a cockerel sqwaking in your ear, although Professor Bontoni's laboratory tests indicate that the defences would have been more or less silent.

Another image shows a man bending over, with words emerging from his bottom. 'This, we think, is a depiction of a PPASV spokesman,' says Dr Thacker.

'PPASV also sent people to Herculaneum to persuade the citizens that the defensive measures would "blight their lives" and "kill the countryside". As we all know, Herculaneum was also destroyed. But perhaps, if people hadn't got caught up in the PPASV madness, they might have been able to save themselves and their cities.'

Professor Bontoni agrees. 'These were not the brightest of people. I mean, when you think about it, what kind of person would campaign so dishonestly against such a vital and effective scheme, one which would have provided many benefits, not least of all, of course, the protection of the area against a massive disaster?

'Luckily for us all, people are a lot more sensible and intelligent nowadays.'

Saturday, 19 September 2009

VVASP LIE No. 2

What can you do, eh? The truth is out there. It's already known to millions, and for those who don't know it yet it's not difficult to find out.

And here's the truth:

MODERN WINDFARMS ARE PRETTY WELL SILENT.

But, like other nimby groups, VVASP are committed to the Big Lie Principle: tell a lie (preferably a whopper) enough times, and some people will believe you.

Now, thanks to the BBC, we know that there are residents of Atch, Church and Sheriffs Lenches who still believe that windfarms are noisy. They've fallen for that great Big Lie, that windfarms sound like helicopters approaching, or they make a 'whoomp-whoomp' sound.

Ever been anywhere near a windfarm? If you have, you'll know what a load of claptrap the deluded, misled nimbies of Lench are talking.

If you haven't, you might be inclined to believe VVASP. Interestingly, a small number of VVASP extremists did go to visit a windfarm.

They made no recording of their visit. They just came back saying that what they'd discovered was 'alarming'.

Arguably, what was so alarming to them was the discovery that windfarms make no noise. Hence their failure to make a recording.

Instead, their pseudo-scientific leader has found a 'recording', somewhere or other, of what he says is a windfarm, and they play this as loud as they think they'll get away with at any and every available opportunity.

It's the Big Lie all over again. But if you want to know the truth - go visit a windfarm, either in the UK or in continental Europe. You'll be amazed ... at how quiet they are.

Of course, sooner or later everyone is going to be pretty familiar with the minimal noise output of windfarms. It's only while so many people are so ignorant in this matter that recklessly irresponsible nimby groups like VVASP can make their inaccurate and misleading claims.

And if they fail to convince you about the non-existent 'whoomp-whoomp' noise of windfarms, they'll try a more desperate, and more irresponsible, tack. They'll start talking about a made-up kind of noise that acoustic engineers can't measure and most people can't hear.

The only people who can 'hear' this strange, unrecordable noise are those who were convinced by nimbies that they'd hear one.

The liars - sorry, protesters - claim that this difficult-to-pin-down noise is a form of infrasound.

Well, Dr Geoff Leventhall, expert consultant in Noise Vibration and Acoustics, authored a DEFRA report on infrasound. In contrast to the sort of gobbledegook the nimbies rely on for their so-called facts, Dr Leventhall's report was peer-reviewed. And this is the conclusion he reached:

"I can state quite categorically that there is no significant infrasound from current designs of wind turbines. To say that there is an infrasound problem is one of the hares which objectors to windfarms like to run."

In other words, the nimbies LIE about infrasound from wind turbines (Dr Leventhall put it more politely than that, but that is what he was saying).

So - windfarms are not noisy (that's easy to prove: just visit one) and they don't create magical, mystical, let's-pretend kinds of noise.

Why, then, are so many in the Lenches convinced that they do? (VVASP lies, of course!)

And why does BBC Midlands Today insist on airing the views of ignorant, misinformed, deluded nimbies rather than giving us the facts?

How are we ever going to move forwards while noisy nimbies get to tell lies all the time and responsible media outlets refuse to tell the truth???

The simple fact is, WINDFARMS ARE NOT NOISY.

Don't believe me? Go visit one. You'll be pleasantly surprised.